At first I didn’t want to read this book. I didn’t really liked the cover, I’m not a fan of the watermelon pattern because it feels a little childish to me (like patches on a pair of Osh Kosh overalls) and I didn’t really like the title because it reminded me of the song. I’m still a little perplexed by the title…. But some of the other children’s librarian nominated it for our Mock Awards. Normally I’m in agreement with what we nominate so I was prepared to kick myself in the butt for judging this particular book by its cover.
I didn’t love it.
I guess the main character was pretty decently developed. And all the plot points were hit on nicely. It should have been the kind of book that makes me cry: the mother has Schizophrenia, has stopped taking her medication, and the family farm is failing, instead it felt like it lacked emotional charge. It read a bit predictable and I couldn’t help but feel like Della underwent an unrealistic personality change in too short a time period; a forced resolution in a story without a resolution.
But here’s where I want to try and reframe my perspective: I thought authentic emotion was missing BUT maybe it's perfect for the age group. Maybe it felt predictable because pride is so familiar to us. Exhausting and boring as it is, most of us let pride interfere. Maybe as adults we want children to be children so badly we forget that most of the time they feel the weight of the world, they feel responsible, they feel adult. Maybe the emotional charge I felt was lacking, was written in a different form (shoving the emotion down and ignoring it). Final decision: although it wasn’t my favorite juvenile book of 2018, I see its merits and I can see how it can be relatable to children who react like Della to fear.
For Ages: 8-12 years old
For Those That Liked: The Miscalculations of Lightning Girl, The Science of Breakable Things, See You in The Cosmos