The Book of Boy by Catherine Gilbert Murdock


The end makes this totally worth it.  So in the Children’s Librarian world we have what we call award bait.  These are incredibly well written novels with beautiful language, an articulate story, and deeply developed characters.  The type of book that adults love and praise. The type of book that finds its way into school curriculum. The type of book parents shove at their children.  The type of book that children don’t finish. I believe this novel checks off all those boxes. It is beautiful and exquisite. It had a wonderful end that made the entire plot leading up to it, really and truly mean something (extra points because the reader ahem, me didn’t even know it was supposed to mean something).  To be totally clear: the story as a whole was brilliant, but you don’t fully appreciate that until the end.  Getting to the end, well ….honestly.. it was boooorrrriiinnggg. It was sort of drawn out in a Canterbury Tales way (I am not a fan of Canterbury Tales); a pilgrim and a boy head out in Medieval France to gather the Relics of Saint Peter, in order to receive their desired miracles.  I followed through mainly because if the book is even moderately interesting, I’ll commit to finishing it. This is a remnant of some sort of weird competition I began with myself back when I was forcing reading my list of “classics”. I generally tell the children that if their reading for pleasure and not enjoying the book to immediately stop reading it, there are just too many fantastic books that will be right up their alley to waste their time hating a book…. No one should hate a book.   BUT I should also point out that there have been many books that I ended up loving ONLY because of the end. This is one of them. Had I stopped when I first felt mildly bored, I would not have finished. I would not have appreciated the plot progression. Because I’m a 30 year old Librarian, I appreciate plot progression. I live for plot progression and deeply developed characters. I bow to the Literary Gods when a book has a capital E, ENDING!! I am shot with Cupid’s arrow when I drag myself through a book only to be convinced of the author’s genius right in the last three chapters.  I eat up Award bait. Hook, line, and sinker. So to end this review that was more about my tendency to swoon over exquisite endings, I suggest it to any and all adults. I will shove it into your hands, check it out onto your library card, and shout its praises on our Mock Awards spreadsheet. But I probably won’t add it to my collection. I probably won’t suggest it to any of my young patrons. And I don’t really see myself using it in any programs. Because it’s Mock Award Bait: deliciously irresistible to us Librarians, but really just a handful of earthworms dug up from the backyard (brown and bland) to all the children.    

For Ages: 8-12 yrs. old

For Those That Liked: The Unfinished Angel, Bob, Crenshaw

Yoga Pose- Fallen Angel:

*Begin standing with the big toes and inner heels touching. Bend the knees drawing the weight into the heels keeping toe toes light and fluffy.
*Begin by lowering the hips down into Utkatasana (Chair Pose).  Keep the big toes light, while majority of weight is held in the heels.
*With hands at your heart in Anjali Mudra, revolve from your upper chest and twist to land the left elbow onto or to the outside of the right thigh.
If this is plenty, breathe here pushing the palms together to point the right elbow up toward the ceiling. If there is wiggle space, keep working the armpit towards the thigh to deepen the twist.
*Gently place both hands onto the ground shoulder width apart, fingertips pointing away from the right thigh. Bend the elbows toward a 90 degree angle as the feet sweep back (into a variation of supported side crow).
*Bring your elbows directly over the wrists as you lift the shin bones up parallel to the ground.
Keep the inner thighs squeezing and the inner elbows hugging in.
*Lower the head to the ground so that the right side of the face rests lightly on the floor.
*While reaching the left leg straight up towards the sky as the bottom foot (right foot) rotates up toward the sky as well.
Continue to keep the right knee bent.

TO COME OUT: Re-stack the knees into Side Crow before lowering the feet back onto the ground.